Arlo Pro vs. Canary Flex vs. Nest Outdoor vs. Ring Stick Up Cam

 

Arlo Pro vs Ring Stick Up Cam vs Canary Flex vs Nest Outdoor.

The competition for the best outdoor smart security camera is very high and the range of choice can be so confusing.

In this comparison, I look at four of the top cameras.

My comparison looks at over 40 different specifications which are all presented in easy to read charts so that you can find the information that you want quickly.

They are 10 charts in this comparison.

Each charts compares a different set of features and each chart has a “winner”- the outdoor camera that I think has the best set of features.

Hopefully, the comparison will answer most of the questions that you have.

To move between the charts, click or tap on the “jumps” below.

[1] The Main Highlights
[2] The Basics
[3] Security Features
[4] Video & Audio
[5] Power & Storage
[6] Connections
[7] Design & Warranty
[8] Home Automation
[9] Remote Access
[10] Ratings & Reviews
[11] Overall Winner

Arlo Pro vs Arlo Q vs Arlo Q Plus

 

Section 1 | The Main Highlights

Section 2 | The Basics

In this section I compare some of the basic features of these cameras.

If you would like to read a written description of the comparison table and find out which camera won this section,  please click on the “Read More” link below the chart.

Read More

Made By

And so what is interesting here is that all four of these smart security cameras are made by different companies.

Arlo is the Smart home division of Netgear which is a famous company that has been making network devices for many years.

Nest is a company that was bought by Google in 2014.

Canary and Ring are both much smaller technology start-up companies who just make smart devices.

Launched

All 4 cameras were first available for sale in 2016.

The ring launched in February, the Nest launched in July and the Arlo Pro and Canary launched in October.

Weight

In terms of weight the Nest Outdoor is the heaviest camera and it is over twice as heavy as the Arlo Pro.

The Canary Flex and the Ring Stick Up cam are about the same weight.

Dimensions

The Arlo Pro, Canary Flex and Ring Cam are all about the same size, but the Nest Outdoor is quite a bit larger.

Price

Three of the cameras have a similar price of around $170.

Prices are always subject to change so please do check the latest prices on Amazon’s website.

I will include a button at the bottom of the chart with which you can check current prices.

I have included two prices for the Arlo Pro.

One price of $227 includes smart hub but it needs in order to work.

The other price of $169 is the camera without the smart hub.

The Canary flex is $176 and the Nest Outdoor is $166.

the Ring Stick Up Cam at the moment is over $40 more expensive than any of the other cameras it will cost you $211.

 

Section 3 | Security Features

In this section I compare some of the security features of these four smart cameras.

If you would like to read a written description of the comparison table, please click on the “Read More” link below the chart.

Read More

Night Vision

Once again all four of these cameras have night vision.

I suspect that they all use the same technology to provide night vision but I cannot find any specifications relating to the night vision for the ring cam.

The Arlo Pro,  Canary Flex and Next Outdoor all use infrared LEDs which have a range of 850 NM (nanometers.)

This range of NM is known to provide a good quality image in low light conditions.

It also means that the LEDs on these cameras give off an “infrared glow” which might be a good deterrent to any night time intruder.

Facial Recognition

None of these cameras use facial recognition technology which is unfortunate as it is, perhaps, one of the next big things in smart security cameras.

And it is easy to see why.

If a camera can recognise a face, it is the beginning of understanding between if a person is a friend or a foe, a threat or a resident, an employee or intruder.

It is another step in automation.

There are a few cameras on the market that use this technology at the moment: one of them being the Nest IQ.

Motion Detection

All of these cameras have motion detection- with adjustable sensitivity and email alerts and push notifications.

Motion detection is the ability of the camera to recognise any movement.

Having adjustable sensitivity is very important particularly to outdoor security cameras.

People who live on busy streets might perhaps want to turn the sensitivity down so that the camera is not constantly detecting irrelevant motion such as passing cars and pedestrians.

People who live in quiet neighborhoods might want to increase the sensitivity.

An added feature on the Ring Stick Up Cam also has motion zones that you can create within the camera’s field of view.

Sound Detection

As far as I can make out only the Arlo Pro and the Nest Outdoor have sound alerts.

Sound detection is the ability of the camera to recognise any sound.

Siren

Only the Arlo Pro has a siren, which is built into its base station. It’s siren is 105 decibels in volume.

None of the other cameras have sirens because they don’t have base stations.

Pan & Tilt

Another popular feature with smart security cameras is pan and tilt technology.

All of these cameras are installed on bases that enable them to pan left and right and tilt up and down- this all needs to be done manually.

Pinch & Zoom

They also have a digital pan and tilt and zoom feature within the app, which allows you to view different parts of the image by swiping and by pinching to zoom.

Some smart security cameras have the ability to automatically track and moving object and keep it in the centre of the image.

One example is the Nest IQ.

Via the app the Arlo Pro and the Nest Outdoor cameras provide digital zoom of x 8.

The Canary Flex and the Rings Cam have x3 digital zoom.

For me the winner in this section is the Arlo Pro.

Arlo Pro vs Arlo Q vs Arlo Q Plus

Arlo Smart Security Cameras- But Are They Smart Enough?

 

 

Section 4 | Video & Audio Features

In this section I compare the most important video and audio features of these four cameras.

If you would like to read a written description of the comparison table, please click on the “Read More” link below the chart.

Read More

Moving onto some of the video and audio features of these cameras.

Lens

The Nest Outdoor is using a 3 megapixel lens.

The Arlo Pro is using a 1 megapixel lens and I couldn’t find any information about the lens that is used in the Canary or the Ring.

Field of View

This is a measurement of how much of the surrounding area a lens can “see”.

The Arlo Pro and the Nest Outdoor have 130° field of view, which is what the top  smart security cameras offer.

The Flex has 116 degree field of view, whereas the Ring has only a 80 degrees field of view which is very small.

Resolution

The Arlo Pro, the Canary Flex and the Ring Cam record images at 720p resolution, which is high definition.

The Nest Outdoors records images at 1080p, (which is full high definition) which makes this camera really stand out.

1080p has been the gold standard for the best smart security cams although at some point in the near future, recording images in 4k or ultra high definition will be available.

Audio

The Arlo Pro, the Nest Outdoor and the Ring Stick Up Cam all offer two way audio, which allows a person who is connecting to their camera via the app to have a conversation with anyone who is adjacent to the camera itself.

Two-way audio is standard across most security cameras and it is a real surprise that it is not yet available on the Canary Flex.

Live Stream

Finally in the video and audio section, all four of these cameras have a live stream feature.

This enables a user to connect to their camera via the app remotely and see and hear what the camera is “seeing and hearing” now.

This is a very popular feature with buyers.

The winner of the section has got to be the Nest!

Section 5 | Power & Storage

In this section I take a look at the power and storage features that these security devices have.

If you would like to read a written description of the comparison table, please click on the “Read More” link below the chart.

Read More

Battery

The Arlo Pro and the Ring Cam are both battery operated. These cameras have power leads but the leads can only be used to recharge the battery.

The battery in the Ring Cam is a much more powerful battery than the battery in the Arlo Pro.

The battery in the Ring is 5200 milliamps, where has the battery in the Arlo Pro is 2440 milliamps.

The battery in the Canary Flex has an even greater capacity it is 6700 milliamps which is huge comparatively.

Power Adapter

Also the Canary Flex can run on battery as well as running on an power cable

This suggests that the battery in the Ring Cam should last a lot longer than the battery in the Arlo Pro.

the Nest Outdoor camera can only be powered by a power cable. It doesn’t have a battery.

It has a very long power cable which measures 25 feet.

Solar Panel

The Ring Cam is the only camera which uses solar power.

You can buy a small solar panel and plug it in next to your camera so that the battery will never go flat.

This is a very very new and innovative way for a smart device to be powered.

None of the other three cameras in this comparison can use a solar panel.

It will be interesting to see how widespread the use of solar panels becomes in charging devices that are used outdoors.

Power over Ethernet

None of these cameras are powered with power over ethernet.

The reason that this feature is included in this comparison is that another Arlo camera, the Q Plus, is powered via ethernet.

Cloud Storage

All four of these cameras would want their owners to use their cloud storage services because most of them have a monthly subscription to pay.

Alternatives to cloud storage for these devices are very, very limited.

Arlo

The Arlo Pro has 3 plans.

Firstly  it has a seven day storage plan which is free. In this plan all of your recordings are stored and kept for 7 days.

Secondly is a 30-day storage plan which will cost you $9.99 a month or $99.99 a year.

This option stores and keeps your recordings for 30 days.

Thirdly is a 60 day storage plan which is $14.99 a month and $149.99 for the year.

In this final option your recordings are stored for 60 days.

Canary Flex

The Canary flex has two storage plans which seems very simple.

The first plan is free and it will store all of your footage for 24 hours.

However, for $9.99 a month you can store an unlimited number of recordings for an unlimited amount of time- as long as you continue to pay the subscription.

Nest Outdoor

The Nest Outdoor has two paid storage plans.

The 10 day plan will store all of your recordings for 10 days and it will cost you $10 per month or $100 per year.

Or there is the 30-day storage plan which will keep all of your recordings for 30 days and that will cost you $30 per month or $300 per year.

Ring Cam

Finally the Ring Cam has three different plans.

Firstly, it has a free 30 day trial.

Or you can pay $30 per year for unlimited storage per camera.

Or you can pay $100 a year for unlimited storage with unlimited cameras.

Alternative Storage Methods

As I said earlier, the options for using non cloud storage are very limited.

The Nest and the Ring have no alternatives.

The Flex will enable you to download your recordings to your smartphone which you can then transfer to another backup device.

With the Arlo Pro you can store things locally on a USB device but this backup only works if you are already paying for one of their cloud plans.

I don’t know about you, but my section winner is the Canary Flex

 

 

Section 6 | Connections

In this section I take a look at how these cameras connect to networks and other devices.

If you would like to read a written description of the comparison table, please click on the “Read More” link below the chart.

Read More

Wi-Fi

All 4 of these cameras use a wi-fi network to connect.

The Canary Flex, the Nest Outdoor and the Ring connect directly to your home wi-fi network.

The Flex and the Nest Outdoor Cam connect to routers that run at either 2. 4 gigahertz or 5 gigahertz speeds whereas the Ring can only connect to home routers that run at a 2.4 gigahertz.

The Arlo Pro uses uses a wireless protocol to connect to its own smart hub.

Unfortunately I can’t find any details about the sort of wi-fi that it uses to connect to its hub.

It cannot be directly connected to your home wifi unfortunately.

However the good news is that you can connect lots of Arlo Pros to a single base station.

So once you buy one why not buy more?!

Ethernet

Some smart security cameras enable the user to connect to their router using an ethernet cable but none of these cameras have that as an option.

The Arlo Pro uses an ethernet cable to connect between the smart hub and the router.

4G

The next feature in this comparison is 4G and the reason that this is in my comparison is because Canary were working with Verizon to develop a weatherproof mount containing a 4G SIM card.

This would be an alternative means of providing a Wi-Fi connection. And it would be very useful for people who want to position their camera where they cannot connect to their home wi-fi.

However, I think that the prices of 4G data plans currently are still too high for this option to be widely popular.

None of the other smart cameras have any special weatherproof devices that can provide a 4G connection.

Bluetooth

The Flex and the Nest Outdoor recommend using a smartphone with a Bluetooth connection during setup.

The Arlo Pro and the Stick Up Cam do not use Bluetooth in any way.

Encryption

And finally in this section let’s take a brief look at encryption.

A few minutes ago we were discussing the different cloud storage options for all of these cameras.

Three of these cameras use 128-bit AES TLS encryption as your recordings are being uploaded.

Those cameras are the Pro, Outdoor and Stick Up.

This is the same level of encryption that banks use and so it is very secure.

But the Flex takes security one step further by providing 256 bit encryption.

Once again, the Canary Flex is my section winner.

 

Section 7 | Design & Warranty

In this section I take a look at the design and warranties  on these devices.

If you would like to read a written description of the comparison table, please click on the “Read More” link below the chart.

Read More

Color

All of the Cameras only come in one choice of colour.

The Pro is white, the Flex is black, the Outdoor is white and the Ring is black.

It seems extraordinary to me that most smart devices are only available in one colour!

The slight exception to this is that you can buy different coloured silicone covers for your Arlo Pro to help fit with the colour scheme of your house or if you want to hide it you can buy a camouflage pattern.

Weatherproof

Since all of these smart Cameras are meant to be used outside I would expect them all to have an IP rating.

The Arlo Pro, the Canary Flex and the Nest Outdoor all have an IP rating of 65.

IP stands Ingress Protection and these are standard ratings that show, in simple terms, how weather proof a device or object is.

The first number 6 means that a device is totally dustproof.

The second number, 5, means that a device has very good protection against water, such as light rain or light snow.

For it to be protected against a heavy rain or snow storm this number would need to be 6!

It is a real surprise that the Ring Camera is only rated as weather resistant and that it doesn’t have an official IP rating.

As well as an IP rating all of these cameras also have an operating temperature range.

The ranges are all pretty similar but the Arlo Pro has the best one as it operates between -14 degrees to 122 °F which is – 25 to 50 °C.

Air Quality

Some smart security cameras that are available, monitor air quality. But none of these cameras do.

Installation

All of these cameras, with a bit of confidence, can be installed by yourself.

As long as you feel confident using drill and a screwdriver these cameras come with step by step set up guides which are included in the app.

There will also be plenty of helpful installation videos for each of these cameras on YouTube.

However if you don’t feel confident installing one of these cameras or you just don’t have the time then you can employ a reliable and local builder or electrician to do the job for you.

Or if you contact the manufacturer directly some of them, such as Nest, have the team of qualified installers.

Warranty

Finally in this section, let’s have a look at the warranties.

The Arlo Pro and the Canary Flex and the Ring Cam all come with a 1 year limited warranty.

The best of the bunch however is the Nest Outdoor which comes with the 2 year limited warranty.

My vote for the overall winner in this section is the Nest Outdoor.

Section 8 | Home Automation

In this section I take a look at the how compatible the cameras in my comparison are with different home automation or smart home systems.

If you would like to read a written description of the comparison table, please click on the “Read More” link below the chart.

Read More

Home automation is the technical term used to describe the technology that powers smart homes.

It is the ability of smart devices to connect to and interact with each other.

There are a number of different languages or systems that devices can use to do this.

All of the four cameras in my comparison have slightly different compatibilities.

IFTTT

IFTTT (IF This Then That) is an app that allows devices to respond and interact with one another automatically via “applets”.

An applet contains a set of instructions or rules that outline the circumstances under which two or more devices respond.

The Arlo, Canary and Nest cameras have official applets on IFTTT but there doesn’t seem to be any of these for the Stick Up Cam.

By official I mean that there are applets that have been created by the manufacturer themselves- as opposed to applets that are created by enthusiasts.

Amazon Alexa

Quite surprisingly, only two of these devices work directly with Amazon Alexa, a digital assistant that enables devices to respond to voice commands via interactive speakers, such as Echo.

These Cameras are the Arlo Pro and the Nest Outdoor.

The Flex works with an Echo, but only via a few applets on IFTTT.

The Ring Camera seems to have no Echo capability.

Apple HomeKit

None of these Cameras are compatible with HomeKit- Apple’s system for smart homes.

The Nest Outdoor is the only smart camera in this list that works with the Nest smart home system and only the Canary works with Wink which is a very popular system.

The Arlo and Ring cameras are the only two that work with Samsung’s SmartThings.

The Arlo Pro wins this section.

Section 9 | Remote Access

In this section I take a look at the how these security cameras can be accessed remotely.

If you would like to read a written description of the comparison table, please click on the “Read More” link below the chart.

Read More

Remote access is the ability to control a device without physically touching it. It is one of the most desirable features of any smart device.

It gives an owner to control a device from the other side of the room or the other side of the world.

iOS

The Pro, Flex and Outdoor models can all be accessed on a variety of iOS devices (including Apple TV) as long as the device is running iOS version 9 or later.

The Stick Up Cam only requires iOS version 8.1.

Android

The situation with Android smartphones and tablets is more complicated as the version of software needed can rely on the specific device you are using.

The quickest and easiest way to check is to visit the Google Play Store on the device that you are intending to use and you can find out about compatibility immediately.

For Arlo and Ring Cameras, the device needs to be running version 4.1 or later and for the other two cameras it is device specific.

Windows Mobile

Only the Ring Cam has an app for Windows 10- none of the other manufacturers have bothered with this as Windows 10 mobile has so few users.

The Canary cannot be accessed via a traditional browser but the Pro, Outdoor and Stick Up all provide access via a browser, which is great because it allows “traditional” computers, such as laptops or desktops to be used.

And in this section, I think that the Ring Cam takes it!

Section 10 | Ratings and Reviews

In this section I take a look at the how highly these smart cameras are rated on Amazon.

If you would like to read a written description of the comparison table, please click on the “Read More” link below the chart.

Read More

To finish the video, we will look at the ratings and reviews that these thermostats have received on Amazon.

What I have tried to do is to show some of the most helpful statistics.

To state the obvious, these numbers will change on an almost daily basis but I think that the overall trends that these numbers reveal will not change that much.

Overall Rating

The overall ratings tell us that the Arlo Pro and the Nest Outdoor are most highly rated at 4.3 and 4.4 out of 5 respectively.

The Stick Up Cam is rated 4.1 and the Canary has a disappointing 3.9 score.

Written Reviews

The Arlo has by far the most written reviews- over 6300.

The Ring Cam comes in second with over 3000.

The numbers in pink show how many reviews are written per month and again the Arlo is a clear winner- at nearly 800.

The Flex has nearly 300 reviews being written per month whereas the Nest and the Ring have around 200 reviews being written.

5 Star Reviews

The Nest Outdoor has the highest percentage of 5 star reviews- 74% of all of its reviews rate it as 5 stars.

The Stick Up Cam comes a close second with 72% of 5 star reviews.

In contrast, the Canary has I think a worryingly low number of 5 star reviews (55%.)

1 Star Reviews

The Arlo, Nest and Ring Cameras all have a very low percentage of reviews rating the product as 1 star, with 3%, 5% and 6% respectively.

The Flex’s 1 star rating is high at 14%.

In this section, my winner is the Nest Outdoor.

 

Section 11 | Medal Ceremony

And so in this Arlo Pro vs. Canary Flex vs. Nest Outdoor vs. Ring Stick Up Cam comparison, who were the winners and losers?

In my opinion, the winner and Gold medallist is the Nest Outdoor.

In second place with a Silver medal is the Arlo Pro.

And in the bronze medal position in this comparison is Ring Cam although I think that it was a close run thing between the Ring Cam and Canary Flex.

 

 

Leave a Reply